Taking a break from the political fiasco of our country, here is another subject Mustang takes on with common sense, which as we all know, is a rare attribute in America, and much of that is caused by this subject. This is a topic about which I have some personal knowledge. A female teacher friend of mine was a longtime teacher in what was a good school in a Cook County, IL HS. In fact, her children went there. Then things suddenly changed when they decided to include other parts of the district in this HS. They received Jr HS students from different schools in an attempt to do what I shall call “leveling the playing field” for all students. The things she had to put up with would make the average educated, caring parent cringe with disgust. Administrators who never stood in a classroom. Students who refused to pay attention, would not shut up so she could teach, and constantly told her to, “Go F**k herself.” When her and her fellow teachers tried to send them to the office, oftentimes they had call security to have them physically removed. while fighting and screaming vulgarities. The principal’s answer was and I quote, “Do not send your discipline problems to me, you are the teacher and are responsible for disciplining your own students.” Life in that school district became overnight a war zone; teachers against students and the administrators Unions youy ask? Come on don ‘t be that gullible; they are a major part of the problem. How much do you have to pay a teacher to put up with that every weekday for nine months?
She is now teaching in Catholic school in FL and absolutely loves her job and her students. For her it is a joy to wake up in the morning looking forward to going to her school. I fervently believe our education system is so broken and believe there is no light at the end of the tunnel to fix it, but we shall still continue throwing money at it because that what our government does.
Personally, I believe the downfall of our education system started with Bush’s “no child left behind.” I have some experience giving talks at these “Alternative Schools” where they send those who should be left behind, but aren’t. Trust me, go visit some of them in your area and see for yourself. There may be good ones, but what I saw was an inability to tell the difference between the students and the teachers. When I asked the principal why the teachers were wearing trashy clothes, earrings and tattoos like the students; his reply was “It’s important for the teachers to identify with the students.” Leadership at its finest right?
The Failure of Education
by Mustang
If (fill in the blank) isn’t working out to your expectations, then all you have to do is throw more money at it. That’s the message we regularly receive from people who make their money from selling “education.” But, is it true? Of course not.
The American education system is an utter failure and has been for decades, and there is no more significant proof of that than observing today’s young adults. They have no academic skills beyond cheating on tests; they lack essential knowledge about our nation’s history or even their own states. They are unable to comprehend cause and effect relationships, and they cannot reason. If our education system is the doctor, then we’ve killed the patient.
Educationalist (a term I use in the most disparaging manner possible) Kate Barrington wants us to know about the American education system’s top fifteen failures. None of her “failures” represent the underlying problem of American schools, but here’s what she identified as her most significant concerns:
-
- Insufficient government funding
- Charter schools siphon away money from public schools
- Teachers aren’t making enough money
- Too many teachers are fired for political reasons
- There is too much bullying going on in schools
- Students are “too poor” to learn
- Schools are over-crowded
- Students are too anxious and hyper-active to learn
- Insufficient parental involvement
She never once mentioned political brainwashing imposed on every child in public schools, never said anything about the costly athletic programs that take away time and money from academic curricula, never mentioned the dismal results of “high stakes” testing, or the fact that students receive no training in civics education, are taught revisionist history, or that they are bored to the point of tears in the classroom.
Ms. Barrington didn’t say that our children cannot construct a proper sentence, much less a paragraph, or that an average first-year high school student can only read at the fifth-grade level and cannot perform algebraic computations or has no interest in the wonder of science.
She also never mentioned that the United States (federal and state expenditures) spends, on average, $800-billion on educational programs EACH YEAR. That figure approximates $15,000.00 annually for each child in elementary and secondary schools. Maybe we shouldn’t focus so much on what we spend on American education — perhaps we should be asking what we’re getting as a return on that investment. Are we getting smarter kids who, within a few years, are knocking them dead in the corporate structure, on Wall Street, as engineers, as scientists?
No — actually, American kids (including those graduating from college with a four-year degree) are mediocre compared to the rest of the civilized world. Forty years after the publication of A Nation at Risk, a ground-breaking report by the National Commission on Excellence, America’s kids are dumber than ever despite the doubling of our expenditures on education.
Constructing more schools does not equate to better education — it only means more children per year are less competitive globally. What other conclusions can a rational person make when more than two-thirds of the student population cannot demonstrate mastery in grade-level mathematics and science, reading, or even understanding the history of their own ancestors?
Here’s an interesting statistic: 85% of our nation’s high school graduates each year are unqualified to enter college as freshmen without substantial remediation.
According to the National Center for Educational Statistics, the average expenditure worldwide is around $9,800 per student annually. Around the world, then, nations who spend far less educating their children are producing young adults who can (and do) read, who can communicate well in writing, who understand complex mathematics, and are geared toward careers in science and engineering.
Equally important, we must address the question of whether America’s young adults are as well-adjusted psychologically as their “other world” cohorts. There does not appear to be any evidence to support such a claim. Considering high incidents of violence in schools and throughout local communities, the opposite seems right. America’s young adult is maladjusted, and if there is not a trend toward psychopathic abnormality, it certainly seems that way.
What, then, should we deduce? Should we conclude that in exchange for $800-billion annually, we are getting psychologically damaged young adults? As young adults, our children not only do not know who they are but also don’t care.
Our young adults do not understand that the rights they enjoy extend to every other citizen, as well — so supporting such notions that they must silence a citizen who has different views from their own — forcibly, if necessary — tells us that our education system has grown at least two (maybe three) generations of dangerously maladjusted human beings. Moreover, they are irrational in thinking that such behavior benefits a healthy society.
America is getting no bang for its buck. Rather than demanding more money (to waste), perhaps reduced spending is a better plan. Pay teachers less money, not more. Stop pretending that high school football programs are equal in importance to science and mathematics. Stop spending hundreds of millions of dollars on textbooks that facilitate revisionist brainwashing or communicate anti-white racial biases.
When compared to the children raised in third-world countries, our children are stupid, psychotic, and socially inept. Is this our return on our ever-increasing investment in the American education system? One notable scientist suggested, “Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.” We attribute this quotation to Albert Einstein’s Parable of Quantum Insanity. Perhaps the educationalists should make a note of it.
Mustang also blogs at Fix Bayonets and Thoughts From Afar
Here’s Sleepy Joe’s answer to the severe problem
Originally posted 2021-01-26 11:51:27.
My friend and neighbor was a teacher most of her life. She had to quit when each year she got more out of control students that could not and would not listen or stay in their seats. Some were physically violent or verbally abusive like Mustang related. And the no child left behind had “mentally challenged” students placed in her classroom, that were totally unable to comprehend the lessons. Their failing grades were blamed on the teacher. When she tried to explain they are crawling on the floor and screeching non stop she was told she ” wasn’t keeping them interested enough.” She tried her best for a few years and retired early. And now Biden’s radical keepers want to end charter schools and religious schools and only allow government run schools. Heaven help us.
I graduated a year early from my high school – not because it was easy, but because I was challenged every day in school. It made me excited to do better. Colonel Bathurst can confirm that I am no genius.
I know I was fortunate in that my city had steel mills and oil refineries. They had enough money for education so they did not have to take funding from state and federal sources. As we all know, when you take the “man’s” money you are expected to work down to their level. Another good point was that the city Superintendent of Schools was elected and could not be a teacher.
Since the “no child left behind” mistake, the challenge has been removed as well as responsibility for your performance. The attitude prevails that if you are guaranteed advancement, why put in the effort. I have a difficult time interviewing most people under 40. They have difficulty understanding basic concepts we had to master in grade school.
LOL, Genius, are any of us, but you are one helluva Marine Bill!
When the teacher of one of our daughters called me and explained to me that Candice was a good student but talked too much and was disruptive, I told her: Ma’m, no worries, it won’t happen again. It didn’t…
The biggest problem children have and it bleeds into their education is toxic masculinity… because… 🙂
The Statistics of Fatherless Children
According to “What Can the Federal Government Do To Decrease Crime and Revitalize Communities?” from the U.S. Department of Justice, children from fatherless homes account for:
Suicide: 63% of youth suicides
Runaways: 90% of all homeless and runaway youths
Behavioral Disorders: 85% of all children that exhibit behavioral disorders
High School Dropouts: 71% of all high school dropouts
Juvenile Detention Rates: 70% of juveniles in state-operated institutions
Substance Abuse: 75% of adolescent patients in substance abuse centers
Aggression: 75% of rapists motivated by displaced anger
Lastly, Beverly our second of four daughters, told me when she was 32 that when she and her sisters were young they never got in trouble because they knew I’d kill them if I caught them…
They all graduated college, then got married, and 3 of the 4 have children after getting married. I failed because none of them became a Marine. One was a USAF officer who married a Marine officer, close enough…
Walter Williams had this recipe for success in life.
1. Graduate high school
2. Don’t commit any crimes
3. No children out of wedlock (Man or Woman)
4. Take ANY job
Great article. In my county at least 30 percent of high school graduates are illiterate.
Agreed, I ran a Young Marine unit in IL before moving o FL. I was shocked at the illiteracy of teenagers. They aren’t taught to write for Pete’s sake, they print everything. No idea what Cursive is, can’t add/subtract. Idiots, yet they go on to college and waste their parents $ gettiong some liberal arts degree in something that holds no chance of getting a job. Then of course they move back in with Mom and Dad. Pitiful